Sherlock Holmes and The Shadwell Shadows by James Lovegrove falls firmly into the category of Popcorn Reading. It doesn’t quite make the dizzying heights of Popcorn with salted caramel but it was fairly tasty popcorn, fulfilling my requirement for something none too taxing to listen to whilst working. James Kleinman’s narration was perfectly delivered being evenly paced and not overplayed so there were no spilled tea moments – always a bonus.
Be aware of possible spoilers ahead if you have not read Sherlock Holmes and The Shadwell Shadows
Mr Lovegrove introduces us to the real story behind Sherlock Holmes, a lifelong battle against the forces of evil and the mighty Cthulu. Apparently his other exploits were merely a cover for his true mission. The commonly accepted Conan Doyle version of his meeting with Dr John Watson is exposed as a fiction, the true story being much darker.
A creeping insanity, hints of links to a mysterious oriental drug baron, a slightly batty librarian, evil spirits from the world of H P Lovecraft, secret government involvement (yes you guessed it – Mycroft), upright yet flawed heroes – everything, including the kitchen sink, is thrown at the story. Our heroes dash around London and out into the hinterlands in an effort to prevent the emergence of the nameless horror that will destroy the world. This battle is only the beginning, being book one of a series. Too quick a defeat would not be good for sales.
Whilst every trope that could possibly be included in the book made an appearance, it remains entertaining even if I did roll my eyes a couple of times – maybe more than a couple. It is well written, the characters are delightfully stereotypical and the story barrels along apace. It cannot be said to match the creeping horror of H P Lovecraft’s Cthulu Mythos but it pays a respectful homage. There are lighter moments, even some laugh out loud ones though that might just be my weird sense of humour and memories sparked by too many hours of playing Mansions of Madness and Elder Sign. I particularly liked the relationship between Holmes and Watson, the redoubtable Mrs Hudson is also a joy but my favourite was the irate Librarian whose rage at the theft of a book knew no bounds.
Generally speaking I am not a great lover of pastiche novels but this is an exception. The Holmes of Conan Doyle was treated with respect, whilst being given a thorough makeover. The Cthulu Mythos was blended almost seamlessly, the link to Watson’s time in India giving the perfect opportunity, the homages to some of the more spooky tales from Conan Doyle all helped.
Great literature – no, entertaining – yes, will I read the rest of the series – more than likely when the time is right.
Reading time well spent – 7 / 10
Format:- Audio (available from £5.59 in various formats)
First Published 2016 by Titan Books
Photo courtesy of Jack Taylor on Unsplash
NB:- All Amazon links are affiliate links, as an Amazon Associate I may earn a small commission from your qualifying purchases which helps fund my reading habit, and for which I am grateful.




